Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine

V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University

 

«Journal of Human Geography»

Inter-regional journal

 REVIEW 

Author (s)

Title of the article

The article is corresponded to the topic of the journal

Yes         Partly, need to be clarified

No  

The article contains elements of the scientific novelty

Yes         Partly, in some aspects       No

The used methods are adequate and sufficient for this subject

Yes         Partly          No

The structure of the article is corresponded to the material published in professional journals

Yes         Partly          No

The title, abstract, keywords, UDC is corresponded to the content of the article

Yes         Partly         No

The english-language abstract reveals the content of the main results of the study

Yes         Partly         No

Size (volume)

Permissible       To reduce      To expand

Illustrations (quantity, quality)

Permissible        To reduce     To expand                 To edit

Framed by the requirements of the article

Yes          No

References is corresponded to the requirements

Yes          Partly         No

To change the title to

Additional notes and comments

 

The article:

can be accepted without changes                                                                   

 

can be accepted with minor changes (in working order,                                

without consideration at the next meeting of the Editorial Board)

 

can be accepted after making corrections, with consideration                      

at the next meeting of the Editorial Board

 

should be sent for re-review                                                                           

 

should be rejected                                                                                          

Reviewer:

(academic degree, academic rank,

position, place of work)                                                    (signature)                                              (name)

 

«___________________   _________ 

Review - download